← Back to Labs

A free cart on a roll of the die. Why it fails.

About this demo ↓

Demo only. No payment, no real prizes, nothing saved.

RetiredWe built this offer to test it and found it could be gamed, so we'd steer clients elsewhere. The demo still works, loophole included.

Odds
Prize cap
Cart

Fernwood Pantry

Demo order #FP-20481

Your cart

  • Pantry gift box$50.00
  • Smoked chili oil$54.00
  • Wildflower honey$48.00
  • Toasted sesame crisp, 3 pack$28.00
Merchandise
$180.00
Shipping
$8.00
Total
$188.00

A choice, just for this order

Take the discount, or roll for it?

Covers merchandise only, not shipping. One roll per order, decided before the reveal. Each roll is independent, so this is a 1 in 6 chance, not every 6th order.

Checkout is off in this demo

What this order costs you

Prize value at retail, before product and shipping costs.

Chance of a win
1 in 6 (16.7%)
The matching discount
16.7% off
Expected cost, roll
$30.00
Expected cost, discount
$30.00
Worst case, one order
$180.00

No cap: a winning roll gives away the whole cart.

That one prize equals the margin on about 7 typical orders.

Assumes a $65 average order and a 40% gross margin, for illustration.

Run it 1,000 times

Chance is lumpy. Discounts aren't.

Each run draws 1,000 orders from a typical mix: mostly small baskets, a few large ones and the rare big corporate order. The die and the discount cost about the same on average. The difference is how the cost arrives.

Simulated with the dials above. Not real results.

Run a simulation to see the chart.

Roll (prizes paid out)Matching discountCumulative cost over 1,000 orders

About this demo

Dice offers are going around social media: roll a six and your order is free. On paper it's fair. A 1 in 6 chance at a free cart costs the merchant the same on average as 16.7% off, and it feels far more exciting. We built it to test that, with the dials a merchant would set. The math held up. The offer didn't. The average only holds if every roll is a real purchase, and shoppers have easy ways to roll without paying. Lose, and you can abandon the cart and roll again. Win, and you can still return the goods. Try the loophole above, then read how else it gets gamed below.

Why we retired it

How a dice offer gets gamed

The expected cost is only right if every roll comes from a committed purchase and a loss stays a loss. Each of these breaks one of those.

  1. Abandon and reroll

    Roll in the cart, before paying, and a losing shopper just starts a new cart and rolls again. A 1 in 6 chance becomes a sure thing for anyone patient.

  2. Buy, lose, return

    Roll after paying, and a generous return policy still makes losing free. Buy, lose, send it back, repeat. Every cycle is a free ticket.

  3. Win, then return

    If the prize is a refund, returning the goods afterward refunds the order twice. Waiting out the return window fixes it, and makes winners wait weeks for their prize.

  4. Split around the cap

    With a $100 cap, one $5,000 order becomes fifty $100 orders, each with a full chance at a free cart. The cap stops protecting you.

  5. New accounts, new chances

    Per-customer limits only work if you can tell customers apart. New emails, cards and addresses get around them.

  6. "Every sixth order" is worse

    The literal version is gamed by anyone watching order numbers, which count up one at a time. Order at the right moment and it's free.

Each fix adds a rule, a support question and a way for an honest shopper to feel cheated. By the time it's safe, it has become a capped, post-purchase reward for the next order.

That's a checkout game, and we built those. See Checkout games

Want an offer tested before you bet on it?

We design promotions, build them into Shopify and work out whether they pay, and how they could be gamed, before your customers do. Tell us what you're thinking of trying.

Start a project